Skip to content

June 23, 2026
  • Facebook
  • X
  • YouTube
cropped-cropped-cropped-Essex-News-web-banner.jpg

Essex County's Local Source

Primary Menu
  • HOME
  • IN THE TOWNS (A-L)
    • BELLEVILLE
    • BLOOMFIELD
    • CALDWELL
    • CEDAR GROVE
    • COUNTY NEWS
    • EAST ORANGE
    • ESSEX FELLS
    • FAIRFIELD
    • GLEN RIDGE
    • IRVINGTON
    • LIVINGSTON
  • IN THE TOWNS (M-Z)
    • MAPLEWOOD
    • MILLBURN
    • MONTCLAIR
    • NEWARK
    • NORTH CALDWELL
    • NUTLEY
    • ORANGE
    • ROSELAND
    • SOUTH ORANGE
    • VERONA
    • WEST CALDWELL
    • WEST ORANGE
  • SPORTS
    • BELLEVILLE
    • BLOOMFIELD
    • EAST ORANGE
    • ESSEX FELLS
    • GLEN RIDGE
    • IRVINGTON
    • MAPLEWOOD
    • MONTCLAIR
    • NORTH CALDWELL
    • NUTLEY
    • ORANGE
    • ROSELAND
    • SOUTH ORANGE
    • WEST CALDWELL
    • WEST ORANGE
  • ARTS / EVENTS
  • BUSINESS NEWS
  • OBITUARIES
  • OPINION
  • PAY A BILL
  • PUBLIC NOTICES
    • Place Notices
    • Search Notices
    • Legal Notice Compliance
    • HELP / FAQ
  • UNION NEWS DAILY
  • Home
  • SPORTS
  • WEST ORANGE
  • Seton Hall Prep football team upsets St. Joseph of Montvale, advances to semifinals

Seton Hall Prep football team upsets St. Joseph of Montvale, advances to semifinals

Jeff Goldberg Published: November 17, 2023 | Updated: November 15, 2023 4 minutes read
311 views
FOOT-SHPvStJoes1

SHP quarterback Liam Londergan waits for the snap.

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

MONTVALE, NJ — In a repeat of last year, the No. 11 seed Seton Hall Prep football team traveled to Montvale to take on No. 3 seed St. Joseph and came from behind to defeat the Green Knights 35-28 in the Non-Public “A” quarterfinal on Saturday, Nov. 11.

The Pirates will now travel to Morris Township to take on No. 2 seed Delbarton, which defeated Don Bosco Prep 14-9, at 1 p.m. on Saturday, Nov. 18. Last year in the quarterfinal, the Pirates defeated St. Joseph 34-30 on a touchdown pass with 7.4 seconds left in the game.

This year, senior Michael Dunmore and the offensive line, along with an opportunistic defense, paved the way to victory. Junior defensive lineman Tyler Amato recovered a St. Joseph fumble and the Pirates capitalized with a 30-yard field goal by senior Jack Catchpole with 4:42 left in the first quarter. Later in the quarter, senior linebacker Christian Black intercepted a St. Joseph pass to halt its drive. In the second quarter, St. Joe’s took a 7-3 lead with 7:45 to go and extended the lead to 14-3 with another TD with

5:51 left. 

After St. Joe’s second touchdown, the Pirates drove 59 yards in five plays, as senior quarterback Liam Londergan hit senior wide receiver Danny Easter with a 24-yard scoring pass and Catchpole added the first of four extra points to make the score 14-10 with 2:50 left. 

After the Green Knights turned the ball over on downs, the Pirates drove 35 yards in four plays and Catchpole connected on a 38-yard field goal as the clock hit :00 to make the halftime score 14-13. 

On their first play of the third quarter, St. Joe’s retook the lead on a touchdown 21-13. On its next drive, Seton Hall cut the lead to 21-20 when it drove 65 yards in five plays, with Dunmore rushing up the middle from 31 yards out with 8:55 left. 

After a St. Joe’s punt, Seton Hall took a 28-21 lead when Dunmore had a 55-yard TD run and Londergan hit Easter with the conversion pass on the first play of the fourth quarter. 

The Green Knights tied the score at 28-28 with 6:25 left on a touchdown. On the next possession, the Pirates went 64 yards in four plays and junior Ben Mitrow scored on a 21-yard touchdown run to give Seton Hall a 35-28 lead with 4:45 left. St. Joe’s drove to the Pirates’ 44-yard line and junior Alleem Scott jarred a ball loose after a reception by a Green Knights receiver. SHP senior defensive back Jaylen McClain jumped on the fumble with 2:04 left to play. The Pirates ran out the clock to end the game. After the game, McClain said, “I couldn’t believe it. I saw the ball on the ground and all I thought was to just jump on it. I just knew the offense was going to handle their business and finish the game.” 

Dunmore said, “We knew we were the underdogs going in and we hate that because we know we can’t beat teams like this all the time. In our eyes, this is not an upset. We just handled our business.” 

SHP head coach Bill Fitzgerald said, “I think we talked about last year in this situation and that gave us confidence. You have been there before and you can do it again, and we did it.”

Fitzgerald was named the Super Essex Conference/Alliance Coach of the Week.

SHP game stats:

Passing: Londergan: 12 of 21 attempts, 142 yards, 1 TD. 

Rushing: Dunmore: 18 carries for 208 yards, 2 TDs.

Receiving: Easter: 4 catches for 76 yards, 1 TD. 

Defensive leaders: McClain, 17 tackles, 1 fumble recovery; Black: 12 tackles, 1 interception, 1 sack; and junior linebacker Justin Cook, 12 tackles.

Photos Courtesy of Seton Hall Prep

SHP vs. St. Joseph’s of Montvale, in Non-Public “A” playoffs, Saturday, Nov. 11.

About the Author

Jeff Goldberg

Author

View All Posts

What do you feel about this?

Post navigation

Previous: St. Joseph’s to host Elks Hoop Shoot Free Throw contest
Next: Bloomfield Junior Bengals enjoy great football season

Author's Other Posts

Seton Hall Prep lacrosse team enjoys another terrific season B-LAX-SHPstate final

Seton Hall Prep lacrosse team enjoys another terrific season

June 17, 2026 47
Seton Hall Prep baseball team enjoys banner season BASE-SHP GNT

Seton Hall Prep baseball team enjoys banner season

June 10, 2026 72
Seton Hall Prep track athletes give good efforts at state Meet of Champions LOGO-SHP

Seton Hall Prep track athletes give good efforts at state Meet of Champions

June 10, 2026 67
Seton Hall Prep lacrosse team reaches state final B-LAX-SHPvStAugustine

Seton Hall Prep lacrosse team reaches state final

June 10, 2026 64

Related Stories

BASE-MKA Costa-Fernades
1 minute read

West Orange’s Ethan Costa-Fernandes was a boost for Montclair Kimberley Academy baseball team

Steve Tober June 17, 2026 37
B-LAX-SHPstate final
2 minutes read

Seton Hall Prep lacrosse team enjoys another terrific season

Jeff Goldberg June 17, 2026 47
B-HOOPS-WO Cadeau honor
2 minutes read

West Orange basketball star/NCAA champion Elliot Cadeau honored by Essex County

Editor June 18, 2026 51
BASE-SHP GNT
2 minutes read

Seton Hall Prep baseball team enjoys banner season

Jeff Goldberg June 10, 2026 72
SOFT-WO team
1 minute read

West Orange HS softball players earn Super Essex Conference honors

Joe Ragozzino June 11, 2026 71
LOGO-SHP
1 minute read

Seton Hall Prep track athletes give good efforts at state Meet of Champions

Jeff Goldberg June 10, 2026 67

LOCAL SPORTS

Bloomfield HS track and field athletes garner Super Essex Conference honors TRACK-BHS track honors 1

Bloomfield HS track and field athletes garner Super Essex Conference honors

June 17, 2026 29
Glen Ridge HS girls lacrosse team wins state championship G-LAX-GR state final1 2

Glen Ridge HS girls lacrosse team wins state championship

June 17, 2026 39
Joelle Bernhard excited to be new Bloomfield HS girls soccer head coach G-SOCCER-BHScoachBernard 3

Joelle Bernhard excited to be new Bloomfield HS girls soccer head coach

June 17, 2026 48
Glen Ridge’s Melissa Meyer keys Montclair Kimberley Academy softball squad to banner season SOFT-MKA Meyer 4

Glen Ridge’s Melissa Meyer keys Montclair Kimberley Academy softball squad to banner season

June 17, 2026 52

SIGN UP to receive weekly Local Alerts by email

* indicates required

You may have missed

WO-Soccer Tournament2-C
3 minutes read

Soccer fun is able to raise funds

Cynthia Cumming June 17, 2026 23
BLM-Super Retiring-C
5 minutes read

Superintendent retiring after 50 years

Daniel Jackovino June 22, 2026 47
TRACK-BHS track honors
2 minutes read

Bloomfield HS track and field athletes garner Super Essex Conference honors

Joe Ragozzino June 17, 2026 29
MAP-Tutors Celebrated1-C
3 minutes read

Achieve celebrates its volunteer tutors

Editor June 17, 2026 31
  • ABOUT US
  • CONTACT US
  • CLASSIFIEDS
  • FIND A NEWSPAPER
  • PUBLIC NOTICES
  • ADVERTISE
  • SUBSCRIBE
  • PAY A BILL
  • MONTHLY NEWSPAPERS
  • Login
Created by Worrall Media. Copyright © 2026 All rights reserved.